Original illustration by PestControlBasics.com. Use anatomical labels above to confirm your identification.
π Identification
Shore fly (Scatella): 3-4mm; darker than fungus gnat; short antennae; white spots on wings (diagnostic); runs rapidly across surfaces rather than flying weakly. Breeds in algae on wet surfaces (irrigation lines, wet benches, algae mats), NOT in potting soil. Bti doesn't work. Root aphid: 1-2mm; soft-bodied; waxy white coating; found on roots when plant is removed from pot; aerial plant shows wilting, yellowing, and slow decline with no visible cause.
𧬠Biology & Behavior
Shore flies: Breed in algae β treatment must target algae elimination, not soil. Bti that kills fungus gnat larvae has no effect on shore fly larvae in algae. Root aphids: often confused with root mealybugs; both are underground; root aphids move and have distinct body shape; caused significant losses in cannabis, lettuce, and ornamental production.
β οΈ Damage & Health Risk
Shore fly: nuisance; potential pathogen transfer on feet. Root aphid: significant plant decline, yellowing, stunting; root system destruction; economic losses in commercial production.
π§ DIY Treatment
Shore fly: eliminate algae with 10% bleach solution on surfaces; improve drainage and air circulation; copper-based algaecides on growing surfaces. Root aphid: imidacloprid soil drench; pyrethrin root drench; complete removal and replacement of growing media with sterilization of containers.
π· When to Call a Pro
Commercial greenhouse: professional IPM program targeting specific organisms with correct products β misidentification causes significant product waste and crop loss.